Review – All New X-Men #1

All New X-Men #1The battle for comic book supremacy continues between Marvel and DC.  Following in DC’s footsteps, Marvel does a little reboot of its own, but leaves its continuity in place.  After some title and team shuffling, the new lines are drawn and we now have Marvel NOW!  I am only reading a few titles regularly but trying to get as many of the number ones as I can afford each week.

Following up on the Avengers vs X-Men event, All New X-Men #1 picks up as Scott Summers, Emma Frost and Magneto are traveling the world contacting some of the thousands of new mutants created by the dispersion of the Phoenix Force.  Scott is a wanted fugitive, shunned by most of his former friends and teammates.  He again appears to be working the premise that the ends justify the means.  Storm and the X-Men don’t see it that way and they prepare to go after Scott with the intentions of shutting him down.

All New X-Men #1This is where the story takes an interesting twist.  There are no lengths that Marvel won’t go to these days to sell a comic and they prove it by throwing in time travel into this issue.  Beast (Hank McCoy) travels back in time to recruit a younger, more idealistic Scott Summers to help him stop the present day Scott Summers.  Got a headache yet?

Although the cliché of time travel threw me off of what is otherwise a pretty entertaining book, I sort of had a feeling that traveling back in time was nearly their only option to try to talk any sense into Scott.  His corruption by the Phoenix seems to have taught him nothing.  And even though he feels he is atoning for his crimes, most of his fellow mutants don’t see it that way.

So what could be said here?  Did Marvel need to shake up the status quo?  I’d say probably so since they have slipped a bit since DC’s New 52 took effect last year.  But as much as I hate to admit it, it seems this is yet another thing that Marvel is doing better than DC.  Just by leaving their continuity in place, they haven’t appeared to have alienated the fans as much as DC did.  All the names and events are still around (those who survived AxV that is) and the only real issue here is trying to figure out which new titles to pick up after many were cancelled.

All New X-Men #1All New X-Men is one of the titles I have personally transitioned to after Uncanny X-Men finished its run.  As of the first issue, this will be a title I am going to keep picking up for the foreseeable future.  In spite of the obvious storyline clichés, I really enjoyed this book.  The ramifications of AxV are still being felt in the Marvel universe and since many relationships were made and broken over the course of that arc, it was probably necessary to redraw the borders so to speak.

“When we were young we were always worried about a mutant apocalyptic nightmare!  I’m telling you, if the young us saw what was going on today it would feel worse than the mutant apocalyptic nightmare we used to worry about!”

Brian Michael Bendis does his regular good job with the writing for this first issue, but personally for me it was the art by Stuart Immonen that really stood out.  The cover especially is a masterpiece by its own right; a collaboration of Immonen, Wade Von Grawbadger and Martie Gracia.

So if you are confused by the many X titles out there and aren’t sure which one you’d want to start reading, I would definitely suggest All New X-Men which gives a good jumping on point for new readers.  You’ve done good Marvel…keep it up.


All New X-Men #1



About the author

Bryan Brown

The founder of Word of the Nerd and semi-fearless leader. Bryan is an all around nerd, from Star Trek to comic books to collecting action figures. If it's nerd related, he's into it or at least has an opinion on it.


Click here to post a comment
  • Great review, Bryan. I have one quibble with the premise of this book and that the idea that Hank is bringing back the idealistic version of Scott to supposedly talk some sense into his future self. He’s basically bringing a version of Scott that hasn’t gone through the same trials that the older Scott has. Corruption via the Phoenix Force notwithstanding, Scott’s gone through some stuff in his life that this younger version hasn’t yet experienced, which would leave him very ill-equipped to talk to his older self and expect to make any kind of impact.

    Bendis’s new status-quo, which is still treading the old ground of mutant persecution, would be more interesting if Scott and the other wanted mutants were dropping off the newly discovered mutants at the school, so they’ll be safe instead of just grabbing them and leaving terrorist-level messages via the media.

    But maybe it’ll pick up as the book progresses. At least it’s more fun to talk about than the stuff DC’s doing.

    Cyclops was right!! Deal with it!

  • Time traveling Beast is a bit much, and his secondary, or tertiary, mutation being the reason for it is a huge, are-you-kidding-me stretch, but otherwise, it was well-written, and a surprisingly quick read.

  • And it’s interesting to see, over the past few years, Iceman evolve into an angrier, more cantankerous character. I like “Scott, you’re insane and I want to kick your ass” Iceman more than the “I’m going to hang around in the background and just make ice sleds” Iceman we usually get in X-Men storylines.

  • 300x250
  • New CBC bonus gifts-2
  • NoD_Black_Tall.png-e1582139137446.png
  • Shop Custom Removable Vinyls from Fathead! Turn your photos into professional prints, decals, & murals - Click Here!
  • Metallica The Master Collection Banners
  • Free Domestic Shipping Over $80 120x600

Check out our YouTube Channel

%d bloggers like this: